June 07 2007 - Florida medical errors may become public
An issue of fear and loathing to the health care industry, the prospect of opening secret incident reports, is scheduled to come before the Florida Supreme Court this morning.
Hospitals warn that the decision could squelch the willingness of doctors and nurses to report errors if the court orders opening of any files related to an "adverse medical incident" as decreed by the Patients' Right to Know, a voter initiative that passed overwhelmingly in November 2004. They also warn that it will be expensive.
"Depending on what the court says, it could cost scads of money," said Arthur England Jr., one of two attorneys who will argue the hospitals' case.
Two attorneys will argue for broad interpretation of the voter initiative, often called Amendment 7. They represent patients who have sued hospitals in Lake City and Tavares for medical malpractice.
Patients won lower-court rulings in the two cases that have been consolidated for today's arguments, Florida Hospital Waterman v. Buster and Notami Hospital of Florida v. Bowen.
Lower courts decided that the Legislature violated the constitution by passing "implementing" legislation in 2005 that narrowed the scope of the amendment. Lawmakers ruled out the use of certain disciplinary records in lawsuits and closed records that existed before passage of the amendment.
Christopher Carlyle, one of the attorneys who will appear before the court today, said it's "critically important" to see that the intent of the voters is carried out.
As burning as the issue is to hospitals, doctors and trial attorneys, its resolution carries importance outside the health care industry, said Michael Allen, Stetson University professor of constitutional law.
If the Legislature can get away with undercutting a citizens' initiative, he said, then the voters' power is diminished.
"It's that issue, dressed up in lots of trappings, that's really at the heart of this," Allen said.
<< back
The Pistotnik Law Offices handles all personal injury cases including, but not limited to:Large truck accidents, car accidents, injury cases, injury victims, reckless driving, negligence, torts, car accident victims, damages, wrongful death, vehicle accidents, pedestrians, cyclists, motorcycle accidents, third party lawsuits, damaged cars, insurance settlements, auto accidents, medical bills, permanent injury, rear-end collisions, liability insurance, property damage, minor injuries, insurance coverage, truck accident, tractor-trailer accidents, paralysis, paralyzed, eaglemed, Lifeflight, Wesley Medical Center, Via Christi, St. Francis hospital.
The Pistotnik Law Offices serves the following areas: Kansas, Southern Kansas, Wichita, Barton County, Butler County, Ellis County, Ford County, Abilene, Colby, Dodge City, Garden City, Goodland, Hays, Hutchinson, Larned, Liberal, Pratt, Russell, Salina, Sedgwick, Hodgemen County, Kiowa County, Meade County, Gray County, Haskell County, Finney County, Seward County, Hamilton County, Scott County, Gove County, Logan County, Edwards County, Pawnee County, Stafford County, Reno County, Harvey County, Marion County, Chase County, & Lyon County
The legal information offered by The Pistotnik Law Offices and contained herein, regarding Kansas legal statutes and Kansas claimants' rights, is general in scope. No legal attorney / client relationship with our attorneys is hereby formed nor is the information herein intended as formal legal advice. Please contact a Kansas lawyer regarding your specific inquiry.See Terms of Use.
|
